free web hit counter Press "Enter" to skip to content

Andrew Sullivan’s ode to testosterone is rooted in stereotypes.

Andrew Sullivan attends the 2017 Vulture Festival in New York City.

< img data-normal ="https://compote.slate.com/images/de0e3477-300a-4775-b553-94e35b807264.jpeg?width=780&height=520&rect=1997x1331&offset=0x210" data-retina ="https://compote.slate.com/images/de0e3477-300a-4775-b553-94e35b807264.jpeg?width=780&height=520&rect=1997x1331&offset=0x210"data-srcset= "https://compote.slate.com/images/de0e3477-300a-4775-b553-94e35b807264.jpeg?width=780&height=520&rect=1997x1331&offset=0x210 1x, https://compote.slate.com/images/de0e3477-300a-4775-b553-94e35b807264.jpeg?width=780&height=520&rect=1997x1331&offset=0x210 2x"alt="Andrew Sullivan goes to the 2017 Vulture Festival in New York City.">

Andrew Sullivan attends the 2017Vulture Festival in New York City.Bryan Bedder/Getty Images This post belongs to Outward, Slate’s house for coverage of LGBTQ life, thought, and culture.

Read more here. Andrew Sullivan and I havesomething in common. He’s a huge name in writing, former editor of The New Republic, early supporter for legislating same-sex marriage, existing columnist for New York, while I’m simply a trans guy who sometimes composes things. Both of us take regular injections of testosterone– his was recommended for low testosterone levels related to HIV, mine for gender shift– and both of us are fascinated with the psychological and behavioral impacts of the hormone. Sullivan believes testosterone describes most of the social inequality between males and females, which this fact must be spoken in opposition to feminist thought authorities who seek to scam us into denying nature, especially through the #MeToo motion against sexual harassment and assault. I’m not persuaded.

In his newest column for New York, Sullivan wrote that testosterone injects a ” rush of energy, strength, clarity, ambition, drive, impatience and, above all, horniness”into him, and he credits the hormonal agent with”the sheer and tremendous natural distinction between being a guy and being a woman.” It’s not the very first time he’s tackled this ground either; in 2000, he wrote The He Hormone, a love letter to a chemical he believed actually made him”more alive.”As a trans guy, I experienced firsthand the hormonal balance of a natal female, and for the previous 2 years I have actually had my testosterone levels changed to be what nature more commonly gives males of our types. If Sullivan’s beliefs about testosterone’s residential or commercial properties are right, it needs to apply for me as much or more than anyone. My decision: It doesn’t. From a scientific viewpoint, the mental impacts of a drug are far more challenging to study than physical results are. Science can state with certainty that testosterone has actually grown hair on my face, lowered my voice, expanded my neck and shoulders, and rearranged fat away from my hips and towards my middle. It can’t, nevertheless, say anything with certainty about what it’s done to my ideas and sensations. This is partly because thoughts and sensations are tough to measure, however it’s likewise since our beliefs about exactly what testosterone might do undoubtedly influence exactly what we think it has done. This in turn affects both how we actually feel and how we report on what we’re feeling.< p data-editable=text data-uri=slate.com/components/slate-paragraph/instances/cjcqhfkn900093i64fh765hem@published data-word-count =114 > Scientists have actually

tried to study the cognitive and behavioral results of testosterone, and the photo is far from the well-defined natural differences that Sullivan envisions. Greater testosterone is correlated with more aggression– however research in animals and people recommends that experiences associated with aggressiveness might raise testosterone levels, not always the other method around. Studies of cognitive distinctions as they associate with testosterone are all over the place, with the majority of studies finding a restricted result on cognition at finest. Science definitely does not state that testosterone gives guys clarity, aspiration, drive, or impatience. As well as studies of horniness recommend a function for testosterone in male competition more so than in male sexuality writ large. When I started testosterone treatment two years earlier, I can say with outright certainty that the hormone didn’t turn weak point to strength, passivity to aspiration, or ambivalence to clearness. That is plain nonsense: I had the very same strength, aspiration, and clearness prior to I began HRT had I have after it. I did experience a modification in horniness, but it was a change in frequency, not in kind. Considering that beginning HRT I’ve tended to get horny more frequently, but I did not experience hitherto unidentified vistas of horniness. I have actually never ever felt so horny I could not control myself, nor have I lost my capability to read my partner’s reactions, or to appreciate her satisfaction or her happiness. There’s a common belief among males that male sexuality is a totally different animal than female sexuality, and this is reasonable because they have actually never ever understood anything different. I coped with a female hormone balance for more than 30 years, and so I understand that somebody with estrogen and progesterone and a little testosterone is capable of feeling the specific same horniness. It’s not like remaining in a different world, or perhaps like being in a various area. It’s horniness regularly, or possibly more likely to increase up unbidden. That’s all. Beyond horniness, I’ve noticed other subtle emotional impacts in myself. I cry less easily because starting testosterone. My series of emotions, for the most part, seems to have actually been really somewhat blunted– I feel the exact same things, but a bit less strongly. I’m a little calmer and less anxious. The one exception to this phenomenon is anger or inflammation– I discover I get inflamed just a little more frequently and more quickly. Picture a painting where a couple of hues have been changed a little; some browns are slightly redder, a few blues a bit less vibrant, however the brush strokes are still the same, and the landscape is still totally recognizable. The effects of testosterone– and, in my opinion, the distinctions between the majority of guys and ladies– resemble the subtle modifications to that painting. My subjective experience cannot speak to testosterone’s impacts in all humans or all mammals. Like Sullivan, I might be affected by my previous expectations. I might likewise be influenced by whatever element caused me to be transgender– a cisgender woman who took testosterone might have extremely different impacts, due either to various biological elements or to her discomfort with the masculinizing effects on her body. Nevertheless, my experience(and scientific research studies)assist limit what can be ascribed to the hormone by itself. If testosterone gave guys some special experience that separated them entirely from females, certainly I need to have experienced that by now. Instead, I discover I’m much the same person as I ever was. Incidentally, testosterone treatment has also been studied in males who, like Sullivan, have low testosterone levels, with blended results. Compared with a placebo , males on testosterone reveal slight improvements in state of mind, and in sex drive(although less enhancement than with Viagra). Testosterone does not seem to improve cognitive function or memory, reduce fatigue, or trigger men to walk further, compared with placebo. Sullivan may have experienced something more remarkable, but the research does not support such significant shifts for other guys. Testosterone is a real hormonal agent that takes place in extremely various levels among natal males and women, and there are real differences that result

from that. There’s a broad agreement about this amongst feminists and anti-feminists alike. But we diverge from the science when we start with our stereotypes about males and females– for instance that ladies are weak, communal, self-effacing, and sexless while guys are strong, independent, aggressive, driven, sex-monsters– and lay these presumptions at the feet of one hormonal agent. Sullivan has actually encouraged himself that testosterone makes him more powerful and more driven just like Dumbo convinced himself that he could only fly with the help of a magic feather. More power to him– but he should leave the declarations about human nature to those ready to take a look at the question of sex differences through the lens of science, not stereotypes. One more thing You depend upon Slate for sharp, unique protection of the most recent advancements in politics and culture. Now we have to request your support.Our work is more immediate than ever and is reaching more readers– but online advertising revenues do not fully cover our expenses , and we do not have print customers to assist keep us afloat. We require your assistance. If you believe Slate’s work matters, end up being a Slate Plus member.

You’ll get special members-only material and a suite of terrific advantages– and you’ll assist secure Slate’s future. Join Slate Plus

Source

https://slate.com/human-interest/2018/01/andrew-sullivans-ode-to-testosterone-is-rooted-is-stereotypes.html